BlogFrog

sign up to find and create communities! learn more
Profile picture for MckMama
Welcome to the MckMama Community Created By MckMama

Join this community!
Sign in with Facebook Sign up without Facebook

Community Header
< BACK TO ALL DISCUSSIONS

More Christmas questions--how to balance conflicting family views

Started by Jessica, author of Time standing still 12/16/2009 2:34:02 PM
  I was going to reply to the post about Jesus or Santa, but my reply was getting way too long.
  I am having an issue with how to balance celebrating Christmas vs. not celebrating at all, and Santa or no. So here is our story and I apologize it's so long! :)
   Our kids are 7, 3, and 1. We chose right from the beginning to teach our son (the oldest) that Santa is just like any other character in a movie or on tv. This has worked well for him. It just never seemed logical to us to have to create the idea of Santa ourselves. And then one day the kids would have to know the truth so that they could continue the cycle and create Santa for their kids, and on and on.
  Anyway, as Christians, we have used the occasion to emphasize the miracle and amazing sacrifice of God choosing to be born of flesh on the earth in order to give us the gift of eternal life, while downplaying Santa, and the idea of "baby Jesus," since Jesus is no longer a baby. Our son is now starting to get really exciting about giving and this is wonderful to see. We do put a manger scene out but do not emphasize this from a religious standpoint beyond pointing out that we celebrate our own birthdays so it is nice to remember how amazing it is that Jesus was born. I have always loved Christmas, mostly just because of the fond memories of family-togetherness.
  That being said, I now have some issues. My 3-year-old has seen too many kids programs this season and is starting to argue with us about whether Santa is real or not. I'm starting to question our decision as parents and wonder if she's missing out on too much fun by not making Santa real for her. Which sounds crazy as I'm reading it back to myself, lol.
  On top of that, my parents decided a couple years ago to stop celebrating Christmas altogether. Their reasoning would go along with that of Seventh Day Adventists (which they are not) and the like, if you are familiar with that. So now we don't even have a lot of family togetherness, as there is only my sister's family, my husband's parents, and his sister (no kids). If we were just to go along with my in-laws it would be full out Santa and Baby Jesus, which I just can't do.
  I want to still keep the tradition of family togetherness and celebrating God's love for us through our love for each other, but I'm finding that harder to do each year. I feel like I can't talk-up the merits of Christmas too much while at the same time teaching the children to be sensitive to the views of those who don't celebrate at all. I don't want them to think that others who don't celebrate are wrong in anyway. I guess I'm wondering if there's anyone out there in the same boat, or how people have adapted to keeping different (and sometimes conflicting) traditions in their families.

Replies

Viewing 1 - 10 of 12

Reply by Robin

author of Lolidots Blog 12/16/2009 2:50:34 PM
Hmmmm, here's my thoughts. I think that while Christmas is technically a Christian holiday, it is and has become more of an American holiday. Meaning, I know plenty of people that aren't religious in the slightest but, still celebrate the holiday. To me, Christmas is as American as apple pie and the Fourth of July. I like to observe the holidays of the year, not because of religion, instead because it is a chance to get the family together.

To me, Christmas is about eating too much, opening gifts and spending time with the people you love. Big picture here, I don't think it matters who the presents are from, what church service you went to (or didn't), which version of Jesus you celebrate (or don't), whether you have a Christmas tree or not, whether you say Happy Holidays or Merry Christmas, or any of the other stuff. To me, the holiday season is about remembering to pause and smile at a neighbor, helping someone with a door, giving the mailman a gift, snuggling with your kids on a cold night, getting joy in giving to those you love, gathering with family that you may only see on that one day all year, and celebrating real peace and joy. Those things know no religion or boundaries or miles or mythical present givers or anything else. Love, friendship, peace, happiness, joy are things that are universal and what I feel is the true spirit of this entire season. Those are the reasons I get excited about this season. Because for every elbow bump in the mall, you'll get someone willing to share their Christmas cheer with you. For every annoying family member, you get those moments with the ones you love and cherish. For every complaint about traffic you can find a praise about the goodwill of others. I see people without much in their own lives who give so much of themselves to others because of this holiday season. I see children who have no reason to be happy get smiles on their faces because of the kindness of strangers. It isn't about all of those people, or even all the people in your family, being the same religion or believing in the same things. It's about enjoying the fact that there are other people in this world with us. Embracing them and their differences. Loving everyone and showing our family how much we appreciate them.

And because all of those things are without religious boundaries, I do not consider Christmas a religious holiday. It's perfectly fine if it is but, it certainly doesn't have to be.

I say, celebrate what's in your heart. Teach your children to do the same and there's no way they'll miss out on fun at Christmastime.

Reply by Jessica

author of Time standing still 12/16/2009 2:56:27 PM
That was a very nice reply, thanks! I think you were able to explain the goal I would wish to achieve with my children.

Reply by Michelle

12/16/2009 3:01:43 PM
Just wanted to say that I think that was a wonderful response Robin.  I'm Catholic, but don't give a darn which holiday you celebrate, whether you call it Christmastime or the Holiday Season, Santa or something else....it's just a wonderful time of year!

Reply by Robin

author of Lolidots Blog 12/16/2009 3:15:06 PM
Thanks!! I just have always loved the feeling behind Christmas and I guess now that I've gotten older I've figured out what that feeling is and where it comes from.

I'm actually really glad you asked the question Jessica! After typing out my response I decided to post it on my blog too. Hope you don't mind that I mentioned your name and linked to this thread!

Reply by Jessica

author of Time standing still 12/16/2009 5:15:19 PM
That's no problem, Robin! I'm glad to have inspired some thought on the subject. I never used to think about it at all until my parents changed their position on the holiday. This has left my sister and I feeling sad and like we're missing something, but trying to make sure our kids don't feel like they are missing out on anything. For us, there seems to be this fine line between building traditions with our children while at the same time trying to help them understand why some of our family do not share the holiday with us.

Reply by Robin

author of Lolidots Blog 12/16/2009 5:21:47 PM
Honestly I think you've got to just build your own traditions. That is what your children will remember. I don't think back on Christmases in my childhood and try to remember who WASN'T there. I think and remember who was there and what we did and how wonderful it was. Whether your tradition is something tiny between you and your kids that you do and share every single year or something bigger for more family members, they'll remember it if it's filled with love.

Reply by Ali

author of an ordinary mom 12/16/2009 8:23:29 PM
Blog pic: (want one?)

I didn't know 7th Day Adventists didn't celebrate Christmas... of course, I never claimed to know much about 7th Day Adventists...

Our family hasn't celebrated Christmas in years, but we're not 7th Day Adventists... We're pretty atypical when it comes to Christmas, my extended family doesn't celebrate either, no tree, no gift exchanging, etc... but we do hang out together as everyone has the day off of work! :-)

Reply by Jessica

author of Time standing still 12/16/2009 10:42:43 PM
AnOrdinaryMom--I couldn't say for sure whether SDA celebrate Christmas as a rule or not. I just know that the material that contributed to my parents making the decision they did was from SDA. I don't want to mislead anyone there. :) Thanks for your response. I am really appreciating the many replies. Although we have  been married for 8 years, my husband and I are still going through the learning process of finding out what works for our family at home and how our beliefs fit in with our extended families. We are very close with my family especially, so what each family unit does (or does not do) definitely has some effect on us. Thank you for sharing, everyone!

Reply by Ginger

author of Just A Place to Clear My Mind 12/17/2009 12:46:52 AM
We have never celebrated Christmas in the way other families do.  My kids do not get gifts, do not believe in Santa but they do believe in spending time with family.  My In-laws do celebrate the holidays and every year get frustrated with my kids.  When asked what they want for Christmas my kids say nothing, we have all we need, we just want to spend time with our family.  This year my oldest told my MiL to get a gft for a child on the sharing tree list so that they could enjoy Christmas the way their family celebrates it. I do not think they are missing out on anything, if they need somehting we buy it for them if they want something they earn the money for it. 

Reply by Lisa

author of Oh Boy, Oh Boy, Oh Boy...Life as a working mom with three boys! 12/17/2009 9:00:13 AM

IMHO some people just put entirely too much worry into it all.  But then I'm one that believes that the whole Santa thing is entirely too much fun to miss out on.  As a Christian I do also realize that we have to be carefull to not lose the true meaning but the whole not celebrating I don't understand that.  I don't see how a holiday where you gather with family and are celebrating giving can be wrong!

 

Reply to Discussion

One click to join this community and reply:
Sign in with Facebook
OR
Email
Password
Switch to the mobile version
Please review the rules of this community before posting:

Discussion is welcome here! Please feel free to share, ask questions of each other, talk and even debate. There are lots of interesting, creative and and compelling discussions. Please be sure to talk about ideas and not people. Thus, refrain from name-calling and finger pointing. Prayer requests and links to blogs needing support can be posted in the thread "Praying this Week..." which will be started new each week on Wednesday. Feel free to post prayer requests with or without links for those needing support. Please visit frequently, to lend your support and prayers. Thanks for using healthy and respectful language. We are here to support each other with ideas, suggestions, and tips! Accusatory or derogatory discussions and posts may be deleted as may language deemed inflammatory by the moderators of this community. Repeat offenders may be banned from this community if necessary, although we are hoping everyone stays respectful and this community will self regulate. If discussions take a turn that bothers you, not visiting that thread is the first response! Questions for MckMama specifically should be sent to her using the contact information on her blog. Contact the moderator of this BlogFrog community via email at moderator.mckmama@gmail.com

< BACK TO ALL DISCUSSIONS