BlogFrog

sign up to find and create communities! learn more
Profile picture for MckMama
Welcome to the MckMama Community Created By MckMama

Join this community!
Sign in with Facebook Sign up without Facebook

Community Header
< BACK TO ALL DISCUSSIONS

Pro-Choice

Started by Jimmi, author of Mudpies and Lullabies 1/27/2010 8:29:51 PM

I know this is an extrememly controversial topic, and I don't want it to get ugly. I just want to know how one justifies supporting this cause. For those of you that support abortion:

Why do you support it? Do you also support partial-birth abortion? Why?

Replies

Viewing 1 - 10 of 484

Reply by Amy

author of The Shaffer Spot 1/27/2010 8:37:58 PM

I am against abortion for religious reasons.

Also, in high school I went with a friend to have an abortion out of naively thinking I was supporting her. I have never seen anything so grotesque in all my life and I pray I never will again.

Ironically, I saw this same friend's daughter be born a few years later. What a strange situation to be in. It was supposed to be a joyous moment but at that time I was so sorrowful for the babies she had killed.

I am willing to bet that those who support abortion would at least think twice if they saw it actually happen.

Reply by Stacey

author of Ordinary Days 1/27/2010 8:45:21 PM
I recently saw a study (can't remember where) that said that this generation (those in high school and college) is the most pro-life generation since the 1950's.  They attributed this to the fact that they have grown up seeing sonogram pictures on their frig and on facebook and they have heard the debates related to partial-birth abortion.  I am going to try and find it again.  It was interesting and encouraging.

Reply by Robin

author of Lolidots Blog 1/27/2010 8:46:15 PM
Here's where you are hugely wrong and why this gets so heated, being pro-choice is NOT NOT NOT being "pro abortion". It's being pro CHOICE. It's being of the thought that it should be up to the individual who's body it is to make the decision. Do pro lifers really think that we pro choicers are cheering for abortions? It's insane to me and offensive every time I hear it.

So, let me say it again. Pro Choice does NOT equal pro-abortion. It means pro CHOICE. Break it down simpler? It means to be in favor of having the freedom to make one's own's choices.

Reply by Jessica

author of Life with all these crazy people, me included! 1/27/2010 8:52:02 PM
I think being pro-choice is "for abortion" -meaning you believe abortions should be allowed to happen and that women should have the right to choose if they want one.  Pro-lifers don't think anyone is standing on the sidelines cheering women into clinics and pushing people to get abortions.  Its just a matter of semantics.

Reply by Susan

1/27/2010 8:52:49 PM
Until you walk in someone's shoes that truly that is in an unfathomable situation, I belive in being pro-choice.  If that right were taken away, we would have so many women going to unsafe places to try to do it anyway.  I am not pro-abortion, but I am FOR SURE pro-choice. 

Reply by Kristina

1/27/2010 8:53:38 PM
Nowhere else in society do we have the "choice" of killing another person.  Killing an innocent baby who cannot defend itself.  We have laws against killing animals (cute puppies, kittens, etc.).  We have laws against killing defenseless children and adults who are incapacitated and cannot speak for themselves.  Yet, it's okay to allow women to kill their defenseless baby, just because it hasn't made it out of the womb yet.  Saying you are for "choice" but not for abortion is a cop-out.  Either you support abortion, or you don't.  Pick a side of the fence and then stand up for it. 

Reply by Kristi

1/27/2010 8:54:21 PM

If I could add a little something more to the discussion, I'm also curious about the thoughts from people on the Tim Tebow commercial that is scheduled to be shown during the Super Bowl.  His mother was told by her doctors to have an abortion due to infections and she chose not to.  Tim and his mom are going to appear in a commercial to talk about her decision to carry him to term and not abort.  It's apparently really upsetting pro-choice advocates and I would like to hear people's thoughts as to why his mother's choice is so inflamatory.

For me, I used to be pro-choice when I was younger, but am no longer.  The idea of abortion makes me physically sick.  I do struggle with the issue when it comes to rape.

Reply by Sam

author of Our Family Journal 1/27/2010 8:55:39 PM

First, I do not consider myself to be pro-choice...I am 100% pro-life (my boss, who is Catholic, says I am more like a Catholic in this regard) as I don't personally believe that any spiritual 'good' can come from a 'man-induced' death: murder, abortion, capital punishment and medically induced (sp?) deaths.

However, like I said on the other post ( really don't want to go back and retrieve my comments...but you know what I am referring to, Jimmi) I won't judge those who choose this route...for it is not my place to judge them (thank goodness, phew!).

I have personally seen what abortion can do to someone spiritually (of course, even one can be forgiven for this act...according to my pastor anyways...he said there were people in our church who admittedly had an abortion...who it is, I don't know and don't care, he was just using it as an example to show me God's Grace through Christ)...anyways, that's my 2 cents...so, I just pray that there are less people who choose to, or have to, endure a 'man-induced' death in their lives...on any level.

 

Reply by Sam

author of Our Family Journal 1/27/2010 8:58:04 PM

Oh, and for the record, I don't ever want to tell anyone what to do with their body...that is a different stance about government intervention that I am totally against...the decision should be between a woman and her doctor...I am just not pro-abortion.

Phew, just in case there is anyone reading who doesn't already know I am a Libertarian as well as a Christian.  ;)

Reply by Nat

author of Diary of a Fitness Fanatic 1/27/2010 8:58:17 PM
I get that there is a difference between pro-choice and pro-abortion.  What I can't get past is the fact that it's no longer just that woman's body...there is a baby who never gets the chance to make a choice.  Also that baby has a father and yet the choice is ultimately the mother's.  But even those arguments aside...it's killing an innocent person and I just don't think that's ok.  I will never understand why someone should have the right to choose to kill a baby.
Next Page >Last Page >>
Page of 49

Reply to Discussion

One click to join this community and reply:
Sign in with Facebook
OR
Email
Password
Switch to the mobile version
Please review the rules of this community before posting:

Discussion is welcome here! Please feel free to share, ask questions of each other, talk and even debate. There are lots of interesting, creative and and compelling discussions. Please be sure to talk about ideas and not people. Thus, refrain from name-calling and finger pointing. Prayer requests and links to blogs needing support can be posted in the thread "Praying this Week..." which will be started new each week on Wednesday. Feel free to post prayer requests with or without links for those needing support. Please visit frequently, to lend your support and prayers. Thanks for using healthy and respectful language. We are here to support each other with ideas, suggestions, and tips! Accusatory or derogatory discussions and posts may be deleted as may language deemed inflammatory by the moderators of this community. Repeat offenders may be banned from this community if necessary, although we are hoping everyone stays respectful and this community will self regulate. If discussions take a turn that bothers you, not visiting that thread is the first response! Questions for MckMama specifically should be sent to her using the contact information on her blog. Contact the moderator of this BlogFrog community via email at moderator.mckmama@gmail.com

< BACK TO ALL DISCUSSIONS